(ASIL) American Society of International Law

Readers' Corner

Topical Headings
Admiralty Nuclear Non-Proliferation Arms/Military Expenditures
Peacekeeping Diplomatic Relations Study/Teaching
Environment Treatises Human Rights
United Nations Int'l Court of Justice Legal Practice/Ethics

Admiralty


N. Meeson, ADMIRALTY JURISDICTION AND PRACTICE (Lloyd's of London Press, 1993) [544] --

For society members who practice or resolve admiralty matters, this will be an indispensable reference for handling local or conflict of laws problems involving British admiralty law. As our American law professor population can readily attest, teaching in rem jurisdiction to first year law students is a daunting task. The same uneasy feeling is likely to invade the office of the practitioner dealing with arresting a ship for the first time--especially if there seems to be no British counsel to turn to for advice when an issue of British law appears on the horizon. This publication can help to fill the gap in the available literature on this very specialized subject. (This is one of eight specialized texts on British and European Union admiralty matters available from Lloyd's.)

The first chapter provides an in depth Introduction to the subject. The first major part of the book contains two chapters on admiralty jurisdiction. The other major part consists of six chapters on admiralty practice. The end of the books contains two appendixes with FORMS (120 pages) and further source materials.

Arms/Military Expenditures


D. Gallik (ed.), WORLD MILITARY EXPENDITURES AND ARMS TRANSFERS (23rd ed. US Arms Control & Disarmament Agency, 1995) [paper: 172] --

This is the annual update of a useful statistical product of the US government, adding data to prior editions through 1993. It is essentially a graphic illustration of the arms imports and exports for each country of the world. It also lists armed forces statistics, trends, arms transfers, and the related military burdens borne by each country.

There is both good and bad news. Global military expenditures have reportedly dropped to the level of the mid-1960s. The global arms trade has reportedly dropped to the level of the mid-1970s. There is little room for complacency, however. There is also a fascinating country ranking, as of 1993. The variables reported includes a wealth of information including military expenditures, armed forces, GNP, population, expenditures per capita, and much, much more.

This publication is a must for anyone doing research on military expenditures, arms transfers, and the like. A brief book review cannot begin to do this book justice, in terms of the nature and amount of information thus made available.

Diplomatic Relations


J. Murray (ed.), DIPLOMATIC BAG: AN ANTHOLOGY OF DIPLOMATIC INCIDENTS AND ANECDOTES FROM THE RENAISSANCE TO THE GULF WAR (Trafalgar, 1994) [248] --

This book presents a spectacular potpourri of incidents involving the "inviolability" of the diplomatic bag (as provided for in the 1961 Vienna Convention. It contains much more. Both the public face and private side of diplomacy is illustrated in this compendium of events that have shaped the application of the institution known as the diplomatic bag (or pouch).

The author has collected original correspondence, memoirs, interviews, and anecdotes from a wide variety of sources--ranging from the era of Ivan the Terrible (Moscow: 1557 A.D.) to Saddam Hussein--coupling them with his own experience as the British Ambassador to various countries. The varied vignettes are quite logically arranged in terms of categories such as coups and disasters, pitfalls of protocol, pomp and circumstance, and the like.

Given the media attention to abuse of this diplomatic function, readers should find this book to be fascinating reading on the strategy and subterfuge associated with the institution of the diplomatic bag.

Environment


G. Goldenman, et al., ENVIRONMENTAL LIABILITY AND PRIVATIZATION IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE: A REPORT FOR THE ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION PROGRAMME FOR CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE (Graham & Trotman/Martinus Nijhoff, 1994) [242] --

This book is another in the very useful series entitled International Environmental Law and Policy Series--one which teachers, researchers, and practitioners may consider consulting on both global and European environmental regimes. The title reference indicates the programme endorsed by the Ministerial Conference attended by a number of governmental representatives at Lucerne, Switzerland in 1993--based on an earlier conference in Warsaw.

The varied legal and economic cultures of Eastern European States suggests that privatization, economic transformation, and regional environmental policy are simultaneously surfacing in the midst of conflict. Each of the new governments spawned by the breakup of the former Soviet Union enters the field with internal institutions that are just now establishing themselves as solid entities--among existing regional powers concerned with the resulting impact on their environment. This is the eastern European counterpart to the North-South "sustainable development" dilemma.

This book provides a form of firsthand knowledge of the liability regime being considered by such States in the aftermath of the Cold War, an era which effectively retarded their ability to move in a direction--now suddenly made possible via privatization. The group is thus considering the environmental policies of the advanced States, the usefulness for their respective model, and how to assess and manage the environmental risks associated with a potential lack of cooperation.

Executive summaries are provided for the various panels, whose work is reported in this publication. The panel subjects included the point of view of the private sector, OECD regulatory compliance and cleanup, identifying and managing environmental liability during the privatization process, and legal/policy options for the emerging CEE States.

Human Rights


Int'l Court of Justice




Legal Practice/Ethics


M. Daly & R. Goebel (ed.), RIGHTS, LIABILITY, AND ETHICS IN INTERNATIONAL LEGAL PRACTICE (Transnat'l, 1995) [428] --

This guide is an indispensable "partner" for practitioners who work with foreign counsel. While these pages have reviewed texts containing lists of lawyers, this is the first book encountered by the Editor that provides the host of ethical considerations associated with a transnational legal practice. It is a mixture of articles and panel discussions resulting from the 1991 Stein Institute Conference on the Internationalization of the Practice of Law coordinated by Fordham Law School in New York.

The first five chapters address the duty of loyalty in the following jurisdictions (in order of presentation): United States, Holland, United Kingdom, France, and European/American comparisons. The next six chapters cover the essentials of the following legal systems (in order of presentation): US, UK, France, Germany, Japan, and Belgium. Following chapters then address the duty of competence in the US, France, UK, Spain, and Belgium--again closing with a chapter on the US/European comparison. Chapters 19 through 23 deal with client confidentiality/attorney-client privilege in the US, Holland, Portugal, and the European Community generally. The remaining chapters cover various transnational practice matters including practice under the European Court of Justice procedures, discipline, a proposed global code of ethics for lawyers, and the right of establishment.

Nuclear Non-Proliferation


THE UNITED NATIONS AND NUCLEAR NON-PROLIFERATION (UN, 1995) [paper:199] --

This compilation of relevant documents is obviously quite timely, given the subsequent 1995 UN conference which extended the NNP Treaty indefinitely. The first of two sections is a 30-page narrative introduction by the UN Secretary-General. The other section lists the chronology and events of major significance to the non-proliferation process.

The publication provides an overview of the original 1970 treaty, and the interim developments that necessitated its permanent extension (as of 1995). The key UN and International Atomic Energy Agency documents are conveniently collected between two covers, coupled with the Secretary-General's analysis of the need for constant attention to this threat to international peace. The document collection includes unilateral security assurances given by non-nuclear States to the five "legal" nuclear States, and the treaties establishing nuclear-free zones in Latin America, the Caribbean, and the South Pacific.

One should, of course, hope that the "permanent five" on the Security Council--who retained the legitimate right to possess such weapons under the NNPT--will be able to contain the ability of other States to become members of the nuclear "club" by not signing or observing the treaty objective to control the development, possession, and potential use of these weapons of mass destruction.

Peacekeeping



Study/Teaching


Treatises


R. Higgins, PROBLEMS AND PROCESS: INTERNATIONAL LAW AND HOW WE USE IT (Clarendon Press, 1994) [274] --

This publication is the revised version of the author's lectures--given at the Hague Academy General Course of International Law (the utmost honor in International Law). The thrust of the book illustrates the systemic choice between neutral rules and those which are designed to accomplish recognized values.

The author notes that this is not a treatise, nor is it a textbook. Her objective is not to provide a discourse on the whole of International Law. Rather, it is to identify the major underlying themes tending to drive or to unify the corpus of this branch of the Rule of Law. But it does not shy away from the more difficult and unanswered facets of International Law.

The book is divided into fifteen chapters tracing the outline of the law in a familiar manner, while emphasizing the more salient and connected features often overlooked by the student first attempting to grasp this seemingly amorphous subject. The work thus identifies International Law for its process, rather than merely as a loosely-connected set of neutral rules--with no more than dispute resolution as the object. It is well-written, and thus provides both the experienced and the not-so-experienced professional with a better sense of the raison d'etre of International Law.

United Nations